Unofficial ID Rule - Page 2

Yochoko · 16-08-2012, 12:34 PM

i think that... people who know or are sure about the cheaters, then, they can mail each ally those IDs. the way you expose your own ID might reduce the abuse?? and if people got more time to spend for mailing, can mail solos individually those IDs as well?

Zaheen · 17-08-2012, 06:48 AM

It's just all the secrecy about posting IDs, with all the people *secretly* mailing each other the chances somebody could slip in an ID of somebody they hate could be bigger.

At least if it was public, then people could correct the innocent accusations and victims, and the person falsely accusing lots of people will have a reputation of not having a clue. The players with a good eye for cheaters, will obviously have a stronger decision in the locking.

Don't forget, this suggestion was purely to help our busy Admin who may not have the time to do all this donkey work.

flameharvester · 17-08-2012, 08:37 AM

Just gonna say, if this rule was brought into affect first thing I would do each round is find your id and post it.

lillie · 17-08-2012, 09:04 AM

If the community are going to decide who is cheating then it should be kept very public.... chances are by the time you are accused of this several people have already discussed it and I would want the right to publicly refute it.

Its a wargame ... court martial them if found guilty take them waterboarding

Yochoko · 17-08-2012, 11:26 AM

what i meant was, posting others' IDs anonymously (without revealing your own ID) can create the abuse. so, in-game mailing at least reveals the ID(s) of the denouncer(s). people can just believe what they say or study closely the spy reports on the said cheaters' IDs and make their decision to consider them cheaters or the denouncers abusing. then, they can hit either of them? i think accusing people in public should have the responsibility. posting those IDs while they hide their own IDs doesn't sound too fair to me. :X 'coz there will always be some false accusations as well (or abuse).

Zaheen · 17-08-2012, 04:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flameharvester

Just gonna say, if this rule was brought into affect first thing I would do each round is find your id and post it.

My ID?

When I want people to know my ID I usually go public myself, that's when I'm bored and want to delete. So really it wouldn't make any difference to me.

flameharvester · 17-08-2012, 11:52 PM

Noone would care zaheen I was trying to prove a point, would be so easy to usr it as an excuse. Ill post all my enemies ids during flak wars and bam everyone starts targetting them

Garrett2 · 18-08-2012, 01:28 AM

if it wasn't for the ease of abuse, it would be a great idea.

View Poll Results: Should ID posting be made public?
Yes	8	34.78%
No	15	65.22%
Voters: 23. You may not vote on this poll

17-08-2012, 08:37 AM	#18
flameharvester Head Gardener Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 461	Just gonna say, if this rule was brought into affect first thing I would do each round is find your id and post it. __________________ R42: Flamey Returns - Co-Leader of RSF with recon and shaggy. R43: The World By storm - Fashionably Late R44: 3 Toed left foot of an irish rabbit - Leader of Lucky Charms. R45: hidden horror of the american dream - Flying Ninja Giraffes The obsession Begins! "<DaX\|HL>: Because I've been told 'oh Flamey this' 'oh Flamey that' for about 3 weeks now" Icyyy - "I Want to have flameys gay babys" <Elle> Flamey is the man

17-08-2012, 11:52 PM	#22
flameharvester Head Gardener Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 461	Noone would care zaheen I was trying to prove a point, would be so easy to usr it as an excuse. Ill post all my enemies ids during flak wars and bam everyone starts targetting them __________________ R42: Flamey Returns - Co-Leader of RSF with recon and shaggy. R43: The World By storm - Fashionably Late R44: 3 Toed left foot of an irish rabbit - Leader of Lucky Charms. R45: hidden horror of the american dream - Flying Ninja Giraffes The obsession Begins! "<DaX\|HL>: Because I've been told 'oh Flamey this' 'oh Flamey that' for about 3 weeks now" Icyyy - "I Want to have flameys gay babys" <Elle> Flamey is the man

16-08-2012, 12:34 PM	#16
Yochoko Head Gardener Join Date: Feb 2011 Posts: 310	i think that... people who know or are sure about the cheaters, then, they can mail each ally those IDs. the way you expose your own ID might reduce the abuse?? and if people got more time to spend for mailing, can mail solos individually those IDs as well?

17-08-2012, 06:48 AM	#17
Zaheen BANNED Garden Designer Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: The Clouds Posts: 790	It's just all the secrecy about posting IDs, with all the people *secretly* mailing each other the chances somebody could slip in an ID of somebody they hate could be bigger. At least if it was public, then people could correct the innocent accusations and victims, and the person falsely accusing lots of people will have a reputation of not having a clue. The players with a good eye for cheaters, will obviously have a stronger decision in the locking. Don't forget, this suggestion was purely to help our busy Admin who may not have the time to do all this donkey work.

17-08-2012, 09:04 AM	#19
lillie Harvester Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 173	If the community are going to decide who is cheating then it should be kept very public.... chances are by the time you are accused of this several people have already discussed it and I would want the right to publicly refute it. Its a wargame ... court martial them if found guilty take them waterboarding

17-08-2012, 11:26 AM	#20
Yochoko Head Gardener Join Date: Feb 2011 Posts: 310	what i meant was, posting others' IDs anonymously (without revealing your own ID) can create the abuse. so, in-game mailing at least reveals the ID(s) of the denouncer(s). people can just believe what they say or study closely the spy reports on the said cheaters' IDs and make their decision to consider them cheaters or the denouncers abusing. then, they can hit either of them? i think accusing people in public should have the responsibility. posting those IDs while they hide their own IDs doesn't sound too fair to me. :X 'coz there will always be some false accusations as well (or abuse).

18-08-2012, 01:28 AM	#23
Garrett2 Landscape Designer Join Date: Jan 2012 Posts: 1,661	if it wasn't for the ease of abuse, it would be a great idea.